Editorial Policies

Article Selection Procedure for Review and Publication

All submitted articles will go through the following steps before publication.

1. Initial Screening

The editorial board will check whether the article:

  • Fits the journal's subject and scope.
  • Follows the journal's basic guidelines.
  • Has a clear research topic and objective.
  • Provides original and useful information.
  • Uses an appropriate research method.

Articles that do not meet these basic requirements may be rejected at this stage.

2. Similarity and AI Writing Check

The article will be checked for plagiarism and AI writing status to determine whether it meets the minimum requirements to be selected for the next step. The threshold for both plagiarism and AI writing is 20%, though it depends on the quality of the plagiarism and AI writing.

3. Selection of the Reviewers

The editorial board, through a formal meeting, will select two suitable and independent reviewers who have relevant knowledge of the article's subject. The quality of reviewers should be assessed by checking their previous publications, research experience, and citation records. This will help ensure that the selected reviewers have the appropriate academic expertise and can provide a high-quality review.

4. Peer Review

The reviewers will assess the article based on:

  • Originality
  • Relevance
  • Literature review
  • Research method
  • Analysis and findings
  • Overall quality and clarity
  • Ethical issues

5. Acceptance Rubrics

A manuscript may be recommended for publication when the editorial assessment establishes that it meets the following criteria.

  • Falls within the journal's scope.
  • Provides an appropriate scholarly contribution.
  • Meets acceptable standards of originality.
  • Demonstrates adequate methodological or conceptual rigor.
  • Presents credible and sufficiently supported findings or arguments.
  • Addresses substantive reviewer concerns.
  • Complies with applicable ethical and research-integrity requirements.
  • Meets the journal's formatting and presentation requirements.

6. Editorial Decision

After considering the reviewers' comments, the editorial board will make one of the following decisions.

  • Accept
  • Accept with minor changes
  • Revise and resubmit
  • Reject

7. Final Selection for Publication

An article will be selected for publication if it meets the journal's academic and ethical standards and if it satisfactorily addresses the reviewers' comments.

ARTICLE SELECTION PROCEDURE FOR REVIEW AND PUBLICATION

A simple step-by-step guide for authors

1

Register
Create an author account.
→

2

Log In
Access your author dashboard.
→

3

Submit Manuscript
Complete all submission steps.
→

4

Initial Editorial Screening
• Plagiarism Check
• AI Content Screening
• Journal Scope
• Formatting & Structure
→

5

Double-Blind Peer Review
Independent review by expert reviewers.
→

6

Acceptance Rubrics
Assessment based on originality, methodological rigor, theoretical contribution, relevance, clarity, and overall academic quality.
→

7

Revision
Authors submit a revised manuscript and response to reviewers.
→

8

Final Editorial Decision
Final decision based on the peer-review reports and editorial assessment: Accept, Reject, or Further Revision.
→

9

Production & Publication
Copyediting, DOI assignment where applicable, and online publication.
Track Your Manuscript Anytime

After submission, authors can log in to their DUJMA account to monitor manuscript status, receive editorial decisions, submit revisions, and communicate with the editorial office throughout the publication process.

For further information, please visit the About the Journal page or contact the editorial office.